HOTLINE: New York hedge fund targets $4,000 copper in butterfly options trade

A New York-headquartered hedge fund has opened a position in put options that is structured to pay out handsomely if copper prices trade towards $4,000 per tonne by December, market sources told Hotline.

A New York-headquartered hedge fund has opened a position in put options that is structured to pay out handsomely if copper prices trade towards $4,000 per tonne by December, market sources told Hotline.

The fund has sold 5,000 puts with a strike price of $4,000 per tonne against the December third Wednesday contract, and simultaneously bought 2,500 puts at both $3,000 and $5,000 in the same contract, trade sources said.

The long butterfly put, as the trade is known, was initiated on June 4, and roughly doubled the open interest against each of the three relevant strike prices in the December contract, exchange data shows.

Being deeply out of the money, the butterfly put offers cheap exposure to a sharp drop in copper prices over the next six months, sources said.

Hotline’s analysis of London Metal Exchange options trade data from Bloomberg indicates that the trade cost the firm just under $4 million in premiums, and will pay out a maximum profit of about $58.5 million if the $4,000 puts expire at the money, commissions not included.

Taking account of the premium paid, the options would break even if the December contract reaches about $4,800 and will remain profitable until about $3,200, after which the fund will once again lose money, up to the cost of the premiums and commissions.

Profitability would peak at exactly $4,000 per tonne, as the $5,000 put options could be exercised at a $1,000 profit, without the fund paying out against the $4,000 options. The maximum payout ratio on the trade is nearly 15:1.

“It’s not a bad-looking trade, and the volumes are the chunkiest we’ve seen for a while. They can just put it on and forget about it for now, and see how it looks closer to expiry,” a source at a rival hedge fund said.

In the run-up to expiry, the value of the options will increase or decrease in relation to movements in the underlying copper price, and the party on the other side of the trade, rumoured to be a large bank, may well seek to buy the option back if copper prices move closer to the first $5,000 strike price, sources said.

“From a mark-to-market point of view, they’ve probably already made a bit of money on it,” the hedge fund source said.

The December 2015 copper contract settled at $5,885 per tonne in Tuesday’s official session, down from $5,948.75 when the options were written on June 4.

There are now more put and call options outstanding against the December date than in any other LME contract, exchange data shows.

“It depends where the copper price is trading, but it could make for an interesting end to the year,” the hedge fund source said.

Mark Burton 
mburton@metalbulletin.com
Twitter: @mburtonmb 

What to read next
China's planned sulfuric acid export ban from May 1, historic lows for copper concentrates treatment and refining charges (TC/RCs) and a fragmenting 2026 benchmark system dominated CESCO Week 2026 in Santiago from April 13-17.
The proposal would align the index more closely with physically traded volumes in the region, and enable it to adjust to evolving market conditions. This proposal follows an observed widening of the spread between trader and smelter purchase components of the index and is aligned with a majority of market feedback. Additionally, Fastmarkets seeks feedback […]
Until now, aluminium has been hard to move, not hard to find. Global aluminium supply had remained technically intact, even as output was curtailed in parts of the Gulf, inventory buffers were drawn down or repositioned, and shipping through the Strait of Hormuz was severely disrupted.
Global aluminium producers face heightened uncertainty over power supplies, with oil and gas prices elevated by the closure of the Strait of Hormuz, through which around 20% of global oil and liquefied natural gas (LNG) flows, sources told Fastmarkets.
Fastmarkets is extending the consultation period for the methodology of several of its black mass payables indicators and prices, and is also proposing changes to the names of CIF South Korea and EWX Europe black mass prices.
Rio Tinto Aluminium is expanding its footprint beyond its historic hydro-powered Canadian base, targeting Europe, Asia and Latin America as part of a deliberate diversification strategy, according to the unit’s chief executive officer.