HOTLINE: Protectionism aside, BIR is right to be frustrated about ruling

It was unusual to hear Bureau of International Recycling director-general Francis Veys saying that European secondary copper producers are protectionist, after they lobbied the European Commission to set a very tight limit on the types of scrap that can be considered products, as opposed to waste.

It was unusual to hear Bureau of International Recycling director-general Francis Veys saying that European secondary copper producers are protectionist, after they lobbied the European Commission to set a very tight limit on the types of scrap that can be considered products, as opposed to waste.

Whether or not he is right to make the claim, Veys’ frustration is understandable.

Through its participation in a technical working group, the BIR consulted with the European Commission as it drafted the rule, and the commission has acknowledged it – then roundly ignored it.

It is not the first time representatives of the metals trade and industry have found themselves shut out in the European policymaking process, and once again the union will vote through a well-meaning but wrong-headed policy.

What will be equally frustrating is that organisations such as the BIR saw great opportunity in this new regulation, and viewed it as a way to undo the longstanding Basel Convention rule that classified high-grade metal scrap as hazardous waste in the first place.

Aside from his disappointment, Veys must feel a sense of déjà vu.

“To snub the decision and work of the [working group] is a disgrace … [This] has been forced by the Commission politically and the commissioner,” Metal Bulletin quoted Veys as saying in 1996, as the Basel restrictions came into force into the EU.

… because it will distort the copper scrap market
And what about the issue of the pricing of the copper units in scrap as a result of the ludicrously tight definition?

How will the copper in 97% scrap be priced compared with the units in 98% scrap?

Perhaps a technical working group could be set up to establish whether the commission’s ruling will distort markets.

Mind you, on the basis of this decision, if the group found that was a concern, the commission would ignore it anyway. 

editorial@metalbulletin.com

What to read next
Fastmarkets has launched MB-AL-0424 Aluminium P1020A premium, fob Indonesia, $/tonne on July 9 due to an expected increase in Indonesia-origin aluminium exports. MB-AL-0424 Aluminium P1020A premium, fob Indonesia, $/tonneQuality: P1020A or 99.7 % Minimum Al purity (Si 0.10% max, Fe 0.20% max) in line with LME specifications. Ingot, T-bar, sowQuantity: Min 500 tonnesLocation: FOB IndonesiaTiming: […]
To increase the transparency of our methodology, Fastmarkets clarifies that the quotation period of the MHP nickel payable indicator is the month of delivery, or the month M. Any data points Fastmarkets received otherwise will be normalized to the M month based on the monthly spreads of the prevailing exchange-traded Class-1 nickel reference price, or […]
'Probably miscalculated’ assumptions at Kakula mine force Ivanhoe to overhaul entire Kamoa-Kakula complex, explains CEO Marna Cloete.
Following an initial consultation with the market, Fastmarkets is proposing to:  The new specifications would be as follows, with amendments in italics: MB-CU-0002 Copper grade 1 cathode premium, ddp Midwest US, US cents/lb Quality: Grade A 99.9935% min copper cathode conforming to LME specifications BS EN 1978:2022 – Cu-CATH-1 or Grade 1 Electrolytic Copper Cathode ATSM B1115-10 Quantity: Min […]
Fastmarkets’ 2025 outlook for key raw materials and ingredients used in the production and distribution of fast-moving consumer goods.
Vale Base Metals plans to boost annual copper production to 700,000 tonnes by 2035, aiming to become a top-five global producer of nickel and copper. CEO Shaun Usmar highlights a focus on productivity, cost optimization and sustainable growth. With strong assets in Canada and Brazil, Vale is well-positioned to meet rising global demand.