HOTLINE: Ultra-bearish butterfly put at breakeven as copper price sinks to six-year low

A $4 million collared options trade targeting a copper price of $4,000 by mid-December broke even on Thursday November 12 as the red metal slumped to a new six-year low of $4,800 per tonne.

A $4 million collared options trade targeting a copper price of $4,000 by mid-December broke even on Thursday November 12 as the red metal slumped to a new six-year low of $4,800 per tonne.

The so-called long butterfly put, which a New York-based hedge fund bought from a bank in early June, is structured to pay out between about $4,800 and $3,200 per tonne, and will yield a maximum profit of $58.5 million if the December copper contract expires at just below $4,000, Hotline’s analysis of the trade indicates.

With less than five weeks to go before the third Wednesday prompt date on December 16, copper’s drop back through $5,000 has set the stage for a nervy end-of-year showdown between the hedge fund and the bank that wrote the options, market sources said.

At the time the hedge fund put on the trade, the copper price was a full $1,000 higher, but in the months since, the red metal has been buffeted relentlessly by currency pressures and demand fears. But even with prices now trading at their lowest level since the financial crisis, there are still many analysts and investors betting that the selloff has further to run.

As such, the hedge fund may find that rival investors lend support to its trade towards the end of the year if macro and fundamental conditions continue to deteriorate.

And with the copper industry convening in Shanghai for Cesco Asia next week, updates on the strength – or weakness – of Chinese demand will be coming thick and fast in the run-up to the expiry of the contract.

“They could be laughing; it’s looking like they might have quite a nice end to the year,” a source at a rival hedge fund said.

Meanwhile, the bank may find itself in the unfortunate position of needing to sell into further price drops in order to delta-hedge its exposure to the options trade, other market sources said.

Of course, the market could swing the other way, in which case the bank’s options traders will be able to wipe their brows and pick up the $4 million in premiums from the trade.

For now, they’ll probably keep the champagne on ice.

Mark Burton 
mburton@metalbulletin.com
Twitter: @mburtonmb

What to read next
The publication of the affected price was delayed for 29 minutes. The following assessment was published late: MB-ZN-0110 Zinc spot concentrate TC, cif China, $/per tonne This price is a part of the Fastmarkets Base Metals Physical Prices package. For more information or to provide feedback on the delayed publication of this price or if you […]
The publication of Fastmarkets’ price assessments of the base metals arbitrage for copper, aluminium, zinc and nickel for Friday August 1 were delayed due to reporter error. Fastmarkets’ pricing database has been updated.
The publication of Fastmarkets’ MB-ALU-0003 alumina index adjustment to fob Australia index, Brazil for Thursday July 31 was delayed because of a reporter error. Fastmarkets’ pricing database has been updated.
Key takeaways: US 50% tariffs on Brazil exclude pulp, other major exporting sectors US President Donald Trump has signed an executive order implementing an additional 40% tariff on Brazil, raising the total tariff to 50%, the White House said in a statement published on Wednesday July 30. The new tariffs will take effect in seven […]
Market reactions to the soon-to-be-implemented US copper tariff are driving short-term volatility and supply imbalances while fuelling long-term efforts to expand domestic production, recycling and infrastructure.
US export controls on recycled copper would have unintended consequences that could weaken the country’s domestic recycling and manufacturing ecosystems, the president of the Recycled Materials Association (ReMA) said.