INTERVIEW: Mexico’s illegal coal mines still a major risk to miners

Every day hundreds of men in the north of Mexico risk their lives journeying to the depths of the earth with minimal security measures in search of metallurgical and thermal coal, a union leader warned.

Paragraph entered by Atlantic migration, in order for SteelFirst articles to display correctly on Metal Bulletin.

To reach the minerals they go into rudimentary, illegal underground mines known as the “pocitos” (little wells), which have existed in Mexico since the 18th century, José Ángel Hernández Puente, treasurer at the National Union of Miners and Metal Workers (SNTMMRM), told Steel First.

SNTMMRM estimates there are over 600 pocitos in Mexico, mainly spread across the northern state of Coahuila and usually measuring from one to three metres in diameter.

Local news reports indicate each pocito can produce as much as 30 tonnes of coal per day, which means that more than 6 million tonnes of unofficial run-of-mine coal might be coming out every year of these illegal operations, which are “unlicensed and without basic safety measures”, Hernández Puente said.

This volume compares with the official figure of 16.3 million tonnes of run-of-mine coal produced in Mexico in 2012, which was down by 22% year-on-year, according to the country’s statistics agency Inegi.

“The pocitos are run by men and children equipped only with shovels, pneumatic guns and perhaps gloves,” he pointed out.

Usually, the owners of the pocitos are small companies or entrepreneurs, with miners earning around just 80 Mexican pesos ($6) per tonne of coal, according to local news reports.

“Using a bucket and a steel cable attached to a truck engine, the miners haul out coal,” the union leader stated.

Workers at the pocitos must provide their own equipment, and owners, in a bid to keep costs down, typically do not provide them with emergency exits or well-constructed tunnels, Hernández Puente said.

In order to change this situation, SNTMMRM plans to present a bill to the Mexican congress by the end of the year proposing the regulation of all coal mining operations in the country, the union leader said, without elaborating on the proposed measures.

Current rules
At the moment, there are no laws regulating activities in the pocitos, since they are all considered illegal.

But there are labour penalties.

In April this year, the Mexican chamber of deputies approved a change in the country’s labour laws in order “to prohibit the extraction of coal in wells or holes at depths lower than 100 meters, the so-called pocitos”.

The amendment also enforced greater accountability for worker safety – in the event a worker dies in a pocito, owners will face imprisonment of six to nine years and a fine of up to 10,000 times the Mexican minimum wage, equivalent to 647,600 Mexican pesos ($48,835).

Simply prohibiting the pocitos, however, might not be best solution to the problem, since they have become a widespread activity in Coahuila and other states, with thousands of families depending on income from these operations, according to Hernández Puente.

A report by Organización Familia de Pasta de Conchos, an NGO created by relatives of workers who died buried in a coal mine in 2006, says that the coal region in Coahuila covers an area of 21,832 square kilometres and includes a population of 575,759 people.

“Of these, at least 50,000 children and adults are coal miners [and] many of them work in mines and pocitos,” according to the report.

In some areas, it is actually so easy to exploit metallurgical and thermal coal that people can even make pocitos in their own backyards, Hernández Puente acknowledged.

“People can actually do that, so that’s the reason why the government should regulate [the pocitos],” he said.

Many companies, especially small ones, “do not want to regulate the pocitos because they do not want to invest more money in security, equipment and machines,” Hernández Puente claimed.

Mining law
The subject, nevertheless, is expected to be included in a mining law that will look to introduce royalty payments for the first time in Mexico’s history.

The bill, which was approved earlier this year by the Mexican chamber of deputies and will be debated in the local senate by the end of the year, includes reforms to concessions and mining rights payments.

Mining royalties are part of 95 proposals listed in the Pact for Mexico document released in December last year, the day after the new Enrique Peña Nieto presidency began, aimed at boosting the country’s economic growth through several structural reforms and initiatives.

The mining law also proposes the prohibition of “the mining exploitation of coal through vertical holes [the pocitos]”, but only in the cases in which “the full security of mine workers is not guaranteed”.

This means the government will probably look to assure pocitos are regulated, with workers benefiting from more safety measures.

“The biggest problem is that the pocitos are not [regulated], we hope the Mexican government regulates them,” Hernández Puente said.

What to read next
This price assessment aims to enhance transparency in the Indonesian coke market. Fastmarkets has observed a significant volume of Indonesian coke entering the global market in recent months, establishing Indonesia as a key exporter of coke worldwide since 2023. In the first seven months of 2024, Poland, China and Indonesia were the top three coke exporters globally.  […]
The MB-AL-0408 aluminium low-carbon differential P1020A, cif Mexico was published at 3:02pm London time on May 20 instead of the scheduled time of 3-4pm on May 27. The erroneous price has been removed from Fastmarkets’ pricing database. The price will next be published on May 27 at its usual time. This price is a part of the Fastmarkets […]
The US trade roller coaster ride seems to be flattening, with signs of potential moderation and stability. It appears increasingly likely that our original expectation that the US Trump administration would primarily use the threat of tariffs as a negotiating strategy will be correct. While we do not expect to the US tariff position return to pre-2025 levels, we believe the overall US tariff burden is more likely to settle at around 10-30% globally rather than the elevated rates of 50-100% that seemed possible in recent weeks.
To increase transparency, Fastmarkets has further clarified how it handles price movements during periods of low liquidity. Factors that Fastmarkets may consider during times of low liquidity include, but are not limited to: market fundamentals such as changes in inventory levels, shipments, operating rates and export volumes; relative fundamentals of similar commodities in the same […]
The publication of the following price was delayed for 10 minutes: MB-ALU-0002 Alumina index, fob Australia, $/tonne This price is a part of the Fastmarkets Base Metals package. For more information or to provide feedback on the delayed publication of this price or if you would like to provide price information by becoming a data submitter […]
China has launched a coordinated crackdown on the illegal export of strategic minerals under export control, such as antimony, gallium, germanium, tungsten and rare earths, the country’s Ministry of Commerce announced on Friday May 9.