***LORD COPPER: Banking and trading are not the same

Lord Copper could not normally be accused of socialism or state interventionism, but I must congratulate US president Obama on his statement last night about reforms to the banking system

Lord Copper could not normally be accused of socialism or state interventionism, but I must congratulate US president Obama on his statement last night about reforms to the banking system.

It’s been a bizarre anomaly that banks whose primary economic function has been the taking of deposits and the recycling of those deposits into commercial loans to further the development of national and global economies should instead be dominated by trading in financial markets.

Don’t get me wrong – I have no objection to investment, speculation or hedge funds.

What I would like to see is more honesty – if you want to be a trading company or a hedge fund, say so. That way, banks can be commercial lending operations and speculators and investors can be precisely that.

It would be naïve not to accept that a large part of the boom in asset prices over the last year or so has been fuelled by the cheap (or free) capital ploughed into the banking system by various national governments.

Yes, China is growing rapidly and sucking in commodity imports (just look at oil and copper), but without the stimulus money chasing those commodities, I think it would be difficult to see such a rapid recovery in the prices.

Look at prices and volumes, and it’s not hard to make the case that chunks of the money pumped into the system to rebuild banks’ capital base has been chasing profits in the financial markets.

Obviously, it’s right that investors can do what they like with their money, and speculators have fulfilled an honourable, liquidity-providing role in the commodity markets since their inception.

But if a speculator, or an investor or trader gets it wrong and bankrupts himself, it doesn’t necessarily infect the whole system.

Amaranth managed to destroy itself without taking the world with it.

If a major bank failed though, such is the reach they have as the central pillars of finance that the contagion risks spreading like wildfire through the entire financial system.

It seems to me that that’s a good reason to ensure that banks are not taking huge risks in volatile financial markets.

It makes perfect sense to force them to decide whether they want to be commercial banks or hedge funds, and three cheers for Obama for setting out to prevent those functions being under the same roof.

To move from the general to the specific, what are the implications for metal trading? Well, we probably all agree that bank trading has had a huge influence on the market in recent times, but that needn’t necessarily go away. Reclassifying those activities as speculative, and therefore part of a trading company and not a commercial bank, shouldn’t really change a lot.

If it does, then that would suggest that the capital being used to support that trading is currently part of the commercial bank, which would in turn support the view that some of the activities are being carried out in the grey area best avoided.

It’s a simple conclusion – banking and trading are not the same. Let’s keep them separate, in all of our interests.

What to read next
General Motors (GM) is investing $650 million to develop the Thacker Pass mine in Nevada, the largest known source of lithium in the US and the third largest in the world
Electrolysis processes developed by Boston Metal and Electra that eliminate the need for coal in steel production could be key to a net-zero emissions future for the metallics industry, attendees learned at Fastmarkets’ conference on January 17-19 in Dallas
Low supply, strong demand to spur scrap prices higher in Feb, market says
US deep-sea ferrous export prices from the East Coast to Turkey have plateaued, with a Turkish mill purchasing a cargo at prices stable from the last-reported sale
The current shortage of some higher purity grades of aluminium, such as P0610, and the robust demand for units should maintain the higher differential to prices for P1020-grade aluminium, market sources told Fastmarkets on Monday January 30
We use cookies to provide a personalized site experience.
By continuing to use & browse the site you agree to our Privacy Policy.
Proceed