US court overrules reciprocal tariffs; Section 232 duties remain in place

A US court has struck down key reciprocal tariffs imposed by President Donald Trump, ruling that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) does not grant unlimited tariff authority. While markets reacted positively, Section 232 duties on steel and aluminium remain in effect, prompting continued uncertainty and a likely appeal by the Trump administration.

Court rules against tariff authority under IEEPA

Despite the US Court of International Trade overruling many of US President Donald Trump’s sweeping tariffs, Section 232 duties on steel and aluminium remain in place. In a court ruling issued late Wednesday, May 28, Trump’s reciprocal tariffs, imposed on “Liberation Day” on April 2, were overturned. Also, the 25% ad valorem duties imposed on Mexico and Canada and 10% duties on China were overturned.

Trump justified the tariffs under the International Emergency Powers Act of 1977 (IEEPA). But “the court does not read IEEPA to confer such unbounded authority and sets aside the challenged tariffs imposed thereunder,” the ruling said.

“Any interpretation of IEEPA that delegates unlimited tariff authority is unconstitutional,” the court added.

“The court holds for the foregoing reasons that IEEPA does not authorize any of the Worldwide, Retaliatory, or Trafficking Tariff Orders,” the ruling concluded. “The challenged Tariff Orders will be vacated and their operation permanently enjoined.”

Market response and lingering duties

The decree “has had a positive impact on global markets and by extension US sentiment,” a US-based source told Fastmarkets.

But the 25% tariffs on steel and aluminium, which went into effect on March 12, remain in place.

Some market participants remain frustrated with the tariffs.

“All we can do is wait and see,” a distributor and former auto buyer told Fastmarkets. He believes that Trump will appeal to the Supreme Court to overturn the ruling. This move would allow reciprocal tariffs to go into effect.

Another source said they “are not feeling anything different” about the tariffs.

Trump administration appeals ruling

The Trump administration has already challenged the court’s overruling. The administration filed a notice of appeal to the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit on May 28 following the decision.

Financial markets react to court decision

Financial markets reacted positively to the news. The Dow Jones Industrial average surged by over 500 points in the futures market on the news but fell back to a modest gain after the market opened at 9:30am.

The S&P 500 saw modest gains in the wake of the ruling, while Nasdaq rose significantly. Both indexes have since fallen.

The US dollar surged following the ruling but quickly lost the gains made, according to the US Dollar Index.

Robert England in Delaware, Amy Hinton and Daniel Hillard in Pennsylvania contributed to this story

Fastmarkets provides you with actionable insights. Use our market intelligence on tariff updates to make smarter decisions in agriculture, forest products, metals, mining. Also, utilize these insights for battery raw materials. Find out more here.

What to read next
Lack of standardisation, certifications and market practises is creating growing uncertainty across green steel markets, with implications for pricing, procurement and credibility.
The Trump administration has concluded its investigation against Brazil under Section 301, with the country’s Trade Representative Jamieson Greer proposing a 25% tariff on the South American country’s imports but putting forth a list of exempted items.
A United Auto Workers (UAW) strike at the American Axle factory in Three Rivers, Michigan, that began on Monday June 1 could lead to reduced demand for automotive steel if not resolved quickly, but analysts disagree on whether it will ultimately have a significant impact.
Half a million tonnes of copper is sitting in US warehouses, and the traders who put it there are starting to wonder whether they’ve built a hedge, or a trap.
The newly signed Mexico-EU (EU) trade deal could signal a shift in steel trade toward the EU, but Mexican steelmakers will still prefer trade within North America, a steel producer told Fastmarkets.
The Strait of Hormuz, through which roughly 20% of global oil and liquefied natural gas (LNG) flows, has been closed for three months since US-Israeli strikes on Iran began on February 28, driving up energy costs and putting Europe's aluminium sector under pressure.