Aluminium has challenges in short term but a ‘great future’ – Alcoa’s Harvey

The aluminium industry in Europe is going to have a difficult winter and there is a "great cloud of uncertainty", Roy Harvey, president and chief executive officer at Alcoa, has said

Speaking at the Fastmarkets International Aluminium Conference on Tuesday, September 13, Harvey said that high energy prices continue to add to the uncertainty and volatility we see in today’s market. And although the aluminium industry will face some challenges related to this in the short-term, long-term demand will still be strong.

As it has been a much interesting end of summer, it’s going to be an interesting fall. It’s going to be a very difficult winter in many ways. We’ve seen weak patches [in demand] and uncertainty, but at the same time, I think there is still a very strong case to say aluminium has a great future. It has got challenges in the short term, and we need to see how that plays out.

Roy Harvey, Alcoa

High energy and electricity costs in Europe have taken a number of smelters offline this year. In August, Alcoa announced that it was going to reduce production by one-third at its Lista smelter in Norway.

It said that about 65% of Alcoa’s global smelting portfolio was currently powered under long-term energy contracts linked to aluminium pricing on the London Metal Exchange.

About 30% has either fixed-price or self-generated pricing, but the remaining percentage was exposed to short-term markets – and this included the Lista smelter.

“On the supply side, it is a very difficult time to do business inside of Europe in any industry because of the price of energy,” Harvey said.

“We have a couple of places where we’re exposed to spot energy in Europe and we spent a vast majority of our time trying to think what we do in order to offset that, and deal with it and to make sure we’re making smart decisions on each of these facilities,” he added.

Harvey said that they see a tight energy market across Europe, particularly in Germany, but there is no clarity on what will happen next.

“We can’t predict what tomorrow’s going to look like – you wake up and you look at the headlines to see what terrible things have happened or what great things have happened overnight,” Harvey said.

Despite cuts at smelters, the high energy costs and recession fears are impacting spot demand and pushing European aluminium premiums lower.

Fastmarkets assessed the aluminium P1020A premium, in-whs dp Rotterdam, at $420-460 per tonne on Tuesday – down significantly from the all-time high of $600-630 per tonne in May this year.

But Harvey said Alcoa are continuing to see consumers want metal.

“It’s the metal of the future – it’s a metal that has sustainability built in and recyclability,” Harvey said.

“Our customers are strong. Although there is so much uncertainty in Europe that it is hard for them to have a view on their order book out further than the next few weeks and next couple of months,” he concluded.

#FastmarketsIA

What to read next
The US aluminium industry is experiencing challenges related to tariffs, which have contributed to higher prices and premiums, raising questions about potential impacts on demand. Alcoa's CEO has noted that sustained high prices could affect the domestic market. While trade agreements might provide some relief, analysts expect premiums to remain elevated in the near term. However, aluminum demand is projected to grow over the long term, supported by the energy transition and clean energy projects. To meet this demand, the industry will need to increase production, restart idle smelters and address factors such as electricity costs and global competition.
Read Fastmarkets' monthly base metals market for May 2025 focusing on raw materials including copper, nickel aluminium, lead, zinc and tin.
The MB-AL-0408 aluminium low-carbon differential P1020A, cif Mexico was published at 3:02pm London time on May 20 instead of the scheduled time of 3-4pm on May 27. The erroneous price has been removed from Fastmarkets’ pricing database. The price will next be published on May 27 at its usual time. This price is a part of the Fastmarkets […]
The US trade roller coaster ride seems to be flattening, with signs of potential moderation and stability. It appears increasingly likely that our original expectation that the US Trump administration would primarily use the threat of tariffs as a negotiating strategy will be correct. While we do not expect to the US tariff position return to pre-2025 levels, we believe the overall US tariff burden is more likely to settle at around 10-30% globally rather than the elevated rates of 50-100% that seemed possible in recent weeks.
The Mexico Metals Outlook 2025 conference explored challenges and opportunities in the steel, aluminum and scrap markets, focusing on tariffs, nearshoring, capacity growth and global trends.
China has launched a coordinated crackdown on the illegal export of strategic minerals under export control, such as antimony, gallium, germanium, tungsten and rare earths, the country’s Ministry of Commerce announced on Friday May 9.