China’s export controls disrupt bismuth markets and challenge European industries

China's recent export controls on critical materials, including bismuth, are driving significant price disparities between bismuth oxide and metal in Europe. This development is reshaping market dynamics and posing challenges for industries reliant on these materials.

The wide price gap between bismuth oxide and bismuth metal in Europe persisted in the week to Friday March 21, as metal supply in the region was extremely tight due to China’s export controls on the metal, while oxide continued to flow from the country, according to market participants.

The export control has disrupted the traditional relationship between the two prices since it was imposed on February 4. Previously, the two prices had historically been closely interlinked.

Fastmarkets’ recent price assessment for bismuth oxide, cif Rotterdam was $8.85-13.61 per lb during the first session it was assessed.

And the assessed price for bismuth 99.99% Bi min, in-whs Rotterdam was $30-36 per lb on the same day, down by 5.04% from the $30-39.50 per lb that was assessed in the previous session on Wednesday, March 19.

China produces the vast majority of the world’s bismuth, and prices there have been less affected by the export control.

The assessed price for bismuth 99.99% Bi min, in-whs China was 150,000-160,000 yuan ($20,719-22,100) per tonne on Friday, narrowing downward from 150,000-180,000 yuan per tonne on March 14.

Export controls disrupt traditional price correlation

Market participants told Fastmarkets that, historically, before the export control and subsequent decoupling, bismuth oxide prices were derived using a formula based on approximately 90% of the metal price plus a manufacturing fee.

Although China included bismuth-related items in its export control list on February 4, bismuth oxide was not officially subjected to these restrictions, but some market participants have reported difficulties shipping bismuth oxide to the US.

Prices for bismuth metal in Europe have surged by 550% to record levels on the back of the export control and subsequent supply shortage in the region.

The metal is widely used in metallurgical applications and in the production of oxide, while bismuth oxide is widely used in electronics, optics, pharmaceuticals, catalysts and other fields.

Despite strict export controls on various metals, the export of bismuth oxide should be unaffected. Producers are actively producing and sourcing raw materials, and exporters are quoting as normal, sources in China told Fastmarkets.

“We have been engaged in the export of bismuth oxide, offering both FOB China and CIF prices. The market has been extremely volatile recently, and we are working overtime every day,” a Chinese bismuth oxide exporter said.

Bismuth oxide exports see higher volumes

As bismuth metal is subject to export controls while bismuth oxide is not, the market is reportedly leaning toward exporting bismuth oxide for higher profits. The recent surge in China’s bismuth market and rising prices have also been driven by active purchases from bismuth oxide manufacturers.

“Those purchasing bismuth ingots at high prices likely have their own export channels. Exporting bismuth oxide yields higher profits than selling domestically, and even the price of bismuth oxide is rising now,” a Chinese bismuth producer said.

Following the export control announcement, China exported only 4,000 kg of unwrought bismuth in February, a sharp decline of 93.2% compared with 58,809 kg in January, according to the latest data released by China customs on Thursday March 20.

In contrast, China exported 839,426 kg of bismuth oxide in February. Although this is lower than the 1,707,369 kg exported in January, it is higher than the monthly average export volume of 708,300 kg in the previous year.

Explore more tariffs and trade coverage here:

What to read next
The European Union’s Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism will be implemented in seven months’ time but the region’s steel industry was still not fully prepared for the gradual changes the system will involve, Fastmarkets heard on Thursday May 8 at the Made in Steel trade fair in Milan, Italy.
The global steel industry’s move to decarbonize and China’s penchant for lower-grade ores in recent years have uncovered challenges for high-grade iron ore to live out its value in both the blast furnace-based steelmaking route and the direct-reduction iron process, delegates told Fastmarkets during the Singapore International Ferrous Week (SIFW), which takes place from May 26-30.
Discover how President Trump's tariffs impact the US fluff pulp export market, specifically targeting the EU and China.
The playing field for global iron ore brands could be poised to be leveled, given a recent announcement on lower iron content in a key mainstream Australian direct shipping ore, iron ore market participants told Fastmarkets, adding that the development could narrow the price disparities between major Australian mid-grade iron ore brands.
Vale Base Metals plans to boost annual copper production to 700,000 tonnes by 2035, aiming to become a top-five global producer of nickel and copper. CEO Shaun Usmar highlights a focus on productivity, cost optimization and sustainable growth. With strong assets in Canada and Brazil, Vale is well-positioned to meet rising global demand.
The graphite industry in 2025 faces major challenges, including trade wars, high US tariffs on synthetic graphite and policy changes affecting EV manufacturing and tax credits. Low natural graphite prices, oversupply and slow EV growth make diversifying supply chains essential for market stability.