Border tax ideas ‘very bad policy’: AIIS

The idea of imposing a border tax on imports is "ill-advised" and would harm the metals industry and U.S. consumers, according to the American Institute for International Steel (AIIS)

The importers group on Jan. 27 reacted negatively both to President Trump’s idea of imposing a 20-percent border tax on Mexican goods and to an effort among congressional Republicans to formulate an alternative border-adjusted tax that would eliminate the federal corporate income tax in favor of a tax on all goods and services imported to the United States.

“We view this as very bad policy,” AIIS chairman John Foster told AMM via e-mail, referring to the border-adjusted proposal in the House of Representatives. Foster said such a regime would bring the United States one step closer to adopting a value-added tax (VAT).

“Apparently the idea is that doing this will dissuade the Trump administration from imposing unilateral tariffs and that it will provide political space for corporate tax reductions, which are sure to spark a big fight and undesirable retaliation,” Foster wrote. Aside from being “deemed lacking” in merits, “we have grave concerns (that) a border adjustment opens the door to a VAT-style system in the U.S. down the road.”

Trump’s Jan. 26 proposal of a 20-percent tax on imports from Mexico was met with skepticism from various participants in the U.S. steel supply chain, and other metals suppliers doubted the threat would be taken seriously. Aside from inflaming tensions between the two allies and placing North American Free Trade Agreement relationships in doubt, an estimated 40 percent of imports from Mexico contain American content, meaning a tariff ultimately would harm U.S. producers.

The scenario would be particularly muddled for the scrap trade, which enjoys a robust two-way flow. Trump’s border tax would shred any competitive advantage of the North American network, according to a domestic recycler who does business on both sides of the Mexican border.

“Certainly if this passes in its current iteration, it will be a disaster for the U.S. recycling industry and consumers,” the American recycler said. “It will affect the deeply ingrained supply chain that Nafta has created. It would mean pushing supply back to the lowest-cost nations like (in) Southeast Asia. It will mean undoing the reshoring that we have had from recent years.”

Simply lowering the corporate income tax to 15 percent or 20 percent would be preferable to a border tax, according to Foster.

“It seems that this idea, suggestion, proposal, whatever it is, has not been thought through,” he concluded.

Mei Ling Toh, New York, contributed to this report.

What to read next
The biggest threat to keeping carbon emissions low in the steel industry is imports flowing in from regions where there is a lack of focus on emissions reduction, Kevin Dempsey, president and chief executive officer of the American Iron and Steel Institute, said at Fastmarkets’ second annual Circular Steel Summit on Wednesday January 15 in Houston, Texas.
How Trump’s 2025 trade tactics could shape the future of the US steel industry, with expert insights and predictions.
Trump’s first 100 days, analyzing his policies, impacts, including tariffs, and the effects on global trade
US President-elect Donald Trump’s second term in office will hit the US steel market hard and fast, delegates heard at Fastmarkets’ second annual Circular Steel Summit on Wednesday January 15 in Houston, Texas.
Ferro-alloys market 2025: Trends, rising steel demand, stable policies and key challenges fuelling uncertainty.
European steel and aluminium producers have urged the European Commission to take immediate and effective action to tackle "scrap leakage" so that the European Union can meet its sustainable development aims and secure industrial competitiveness.