Lead byproducts may not be Chinese smelters’ silver lining: 2022 preview

After navigating the rough waters of 2021, lead smelters will likely have another tough year ahead

While primary lead smelters in China are keeping their hopes high on generating more profits from the recovery of byproducts amid losses in the smelting of the base metal, some are skeptical about whether this would be enough of a lifebuoy for them to keep their heads above water in 2022.

Lead smelters have been navigating rough waters in 2021, and they do not have a lot of optimism for next year.

“A major Asian lead smelter that also produces bulk amounts of silver is now planning to extend its maintenance period for next year because they expect low lead-processing charges,” a lead producer source said.

White silver, minor metals such as antimony and bismuth, as well as sulfuric acid are common byproducts of lead smelting.

This year, the sale of byproducts has greatly offset the losses that lead smelters incurred in the smelting of the base metals alone, which emerged as a combination of low lead concentrate treatment charges, high battery scrap prices and more stringent environmental controls in China.

For instance, the export arbitrage window for silver opened in China in the first half of this year, allowing lead smelters to capitalize on the price difference of silver between the international and domestic markets. China sold three times as much silver ingot overseas during this period than a year earlier.

Silver tolling has also become a justification for access to cheaper credit. This revived several mothballed lead smelters in Hunan province this year.

Over the past few months, China’s export arbitrage window for silver was largely closed, though it is now open for certain market participants.

The Ag(T+D) silver contract on the Shanghai Gold Exchange closed at 4,788 yuan per kg – or $21.32 per oz – on December 24. The contract has been experiencing a gradual decline since peaking at 5,911 yuan per kg on May 18.

This is $1.57 per oz lower than a closing price of $22.89 per oz for the equivalent contract on the London Bullion Metals Association (LBMA) on the same day.

“Whether the silver export activity makes economic sense shall depend on the premium figures of individual transaction. It is hard to draw a stable stream of income from it,” a trader said.

Meanwhile, sulfuric acid – another major byproduct of lead smelting – is also unlikely to offer a stable buffer for lead smelters.

Prices for sulfuric acid have slipped to 420-450 yuan ($940-1,007) per tonne in central China’s Hubei province – where it is most actively traded – from more than 1,000 yuan per tonne in March this year, according to an analyst.

“The acid price has fallen by more than half and I believe it has already peaked,” a second producer source in southern China said.

“No one had expected that the price [of sulfuric acid] – which was close to zero before – could reach a high of over 1,000 yuan per tonne early this year,” the source added.

But despite the uncertainties of byproduct revenues and the principal lead smelting business, several lead smelters still prefer to keep their furnaces running.

“Unlike its sister metal zinc, [where] most smelters are owned by the state, a majority of lead smelters are private, so they would face issues with their credit lines if they cannot maintain their operations,” a second lead trader said.

By December 28, the Shanghai Futures Exchange’s front-month lead contract was up by only 5% from the start of the year, lagging behind other base metals such as zinc and copper, which have gained 19-20%.

This means that lead smelters higher production costs are unlikely to be transferred to buyers via a higher output price.

What to read next
The US aluminium industry is experiencing challenges related to tariffs, which have contributed to higher prices and premiums, raising questions about potential impacts on demand. Alcoa's CEO has noted that sustained high prices could affect the domestic market. While trade agreements might provide some relief, analysts expect premiums to remain elevated in the near term. However, aluminum demand is projected to grow over the long term, supported by the energy transition and clean energy projects. To meet this demand, the industry will need to increase production, restart idle smelters and address factors such as electricity costs and global competition.
Read Fastmarkets' monthly base metals market for May 2025 focusing on raw materials including copper, nickel aluminium, lead, zinc and tin.
The Mexico Metals Outlook 2025 conference explored challenges and opportunities in the steel, aluminum and scrap markets, focusing on tariffs, nearshoring, capacity growth and global trends.
China has launched a coordinated crackdown on the illegal export of strategic minerals under export control, such as antimony, gallium, germanium, tungsten and rare earths, the country’s Ministry of Commerce announced on Friday May 9.
Fastmarkets proposes to amend the frequency of Taiwan base metals prices from biweekly to monthly, and the delivery timing for the tin 99.99% ingot premium from two weeks to four weeks.
The US-China trade truce announced on May 12 has brought cautious optimism to China’s non-ferrous metals markets, signaling a possible shift in global trade. Starting May 14, the removal of additional tariffs has impacted sectors like battery raw materials, minor metals and base metals such as zinc and nickel, with mixed reactions. While the improved sentiment has lifted futures prices and trade activity, the long-term effects remain unclear due to challenges like supply-demand pressures and export controls.