Steel traders grapple with ‘nightmare’ tariff doubling

The recent doubling of Section 232 tariffs to 50%, announced by President Trump, has introduced significant uncertainty to the US steel market, with traders reporting disruptions to imports, paused domestic mill quotes and concerns over potential price increases amid modest demand. Industry participants are now assessing how the additional costs will be absorbed across the supply chain.

2025 steel tariffs impact sparks uncertainty among US traders

US steel traders are lamenting the “nightmare” sudden doubling of Section 232 tariffs by the second Trump administration on Wednesday June 4, with many predicting rising prices despite lukewarm underlying demand. The steel import tariffs 2025 impact on US traders is still uncertain. US President Donald Trump said during an appearance at US Steel’s Irvin Works outside Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, on Friday May 30 that he would double Section 232 tariffs from 25% to 50% on steel and aluminium. The news ruined weekends across the nation.

“It’s a nightmare… It’ll destroy the economy, manufacturing — nothing good about it,” a trader said regarding the steel import tariffs 2025 impact on US traders. “Domestic mills will take advantage of this and raise prices. Everything’s been suspended since Friday… I’ve got cargo coming in [this month] and that’s going to be penalized. [The customer] already said they won’t pay for it.”

Import disruptions and pricing pressure define 2025 steel tariffs impact

A West Coast trader said his market is particularly vulnerable to off-the-cuff tariff announcements due to the local reliance on imported steel — which may not be a negative for the Trump administration.

“Importers are scrambling right now, and customers who bought import are also scrambling to ensure they have steel in the next 30-60 days,” he said, adding that it is “probably icing on the cake for the Trump administration — stick it to the states that did not vote for him.” The steel import tariffs 2025 impact on US traders adds another complexity to the market dynamic.

“Materials that have rolled and have shipped or are at the docks about to ship will have to be renegotiated. What means in terms of who shoulders the burder of the additional 25% is yet to be determined,” he said. “So that being said, I fully anticipate domestic mills will raise prices. Not sure if we’ll see announcements, as the optics might look bad. If you call today, you’ll find mills saying they don’t have availability, which is a crock. They are just waiting to see what they can get away with.”

Ongoing negotiations and market confusion reflect 2025 steel tariffs impact

A distributor told Fastmarkets that domestic mills have essentially stopped quoting “because mills haven’t figured out what they’re going to do yet regarding the steel import tariffs 2025 impact on US traders.”

“Mills have paused their quoting,” he said. “We’ve been talking to traders, and they’re definitely concerned depending on how these things shake out. They’ve got steel on the water. They may need to absorb the tariffs or get the mill to do some absorption.”

Yet another trader called the situation “truly interesting times.”

“A 50% mark-up is impossible to catch in the market — to do any business on imports with customers,” he said. “Domestic mills haven’t changed their prices yet, but with 50%, it’ll always be difficult. Maybe not impossible, but difficult for buyers to make economic sense of importing.”

Fastmarkets provides you with actionable insights. Use our market intelligence on tariff updates to make smarter decisions in agriculture, forest products, metals, mining and battery raw materials. Find out more here.

What to read next
Despite the current headwinds, strategic partnerships and continued investment in the right areas, coupled with the underlying strong long-term demand fundamentals, will pave the way for success for lithium producers, according to the participants of the executive panel during the Fastmarkets Lithium Supply and Battery Raw Materials Conference, which took place from June 23-26 in Las Vegas, Nevada.
The US and Europe must adopt long-term, consistent policies and should learn lessons from China, according to lithium industry experts speaking at Fastmarkets’ Lithium Supply and Battery Raw Materials Conference in Las Vegas, US, over June 22-25.
Full details of the prices covered by this consultation can be found here: https://www.fastmarkets.com/insights/open-consultation-on-annual-methodology-review-for-global-pulp-pricing-notice/ During the consultation, Fastmarkets requested comments on whether current discount levels for US market pulp have grown too high and invited open-ended feedback on potential remedies moving forward. Feedback from the industry was mixed. Potential remedies suggested by the industry included […]
Following a month-long consultation period which took place between May 26-June 23, Fastmarkets will launch the weekly price assessment to better reflect the Indonesian coke market, given that the country has been a key exporter of coke worldwide since 2023. The price specifications are as follows: MB-COA-0009 Coke 65/63% CSR, fob IndonesiaQuality: 65/63% CSR, 12.5% max Ash, 0.65% max […]
Tariff concerns and opaque import regulations dominated discussions among aluminium and copper scrap market participants at the 2025 ASEAN Recycling Metals International Conference held in Thailand on June 18-20.
The first publication of the Monterrey HRC and rebar assessments is scheduled for Thursday June 26. The price assessments will be published weekly, every Thursday, 2-3pm (Eastern Time). The specifications are as follows: MB-STE-0934 Steel hot-rolled coil index, delivered Monterrey, Mexico, peso per tonneQuality: SAE 1006-1008 commercial steel and corresponding grades, 48 inches wide, caliber 8-14Quantity: Min 50 […]