EU energy fears eased, but long-term concerns linger

European energy analysts' “what if” questions have turned into “what now” questions in the wake of Russia’s stalled war efforts against Ukraine

Predictions that a massive energy crisis would develop because of overdependence on Russian natural gas, subsequently leading to an economic recessionary crash, never materialized. But the fear remains.

There were concerns that Europe would not get through the winter without Russian gas and that its economy might collapse,

Center for Strategic & International Studies (CSIS)

In a recent report, the CSIS said that “Europe has held firm and adapted. However, despite the strong response to the war, comprehensive structural changes to Europe’s economy and security architecture have yet to materialize.”

Some analysts are now saying the European Union managed to slap a Band-Aid on a gaping chest wound last year.

“Europe kind of lucked out with warmer-than-expected weather and avoiding a lot of these energy supply issues we were warning people about for six-to-nine months,” Nick Webb, director of Risk Management and Commodity Hedging at Ryerson said on a recent podcast.

“There was never that ‘oh-no moment’ where they had to turn off manufacturing and turn off the economy to ration energy usage. But I still think some of those energy issues may be on the table and we just kicked the can down the road several months or maybe even several years.”

The ongoing challenge is the balancing act between keeping the lights on and maintaining manufacturing production – including in the steel sector – amid goals to shed dependence on Russian gas.

Accomplishing that feat with renewable energy and increased liquified natural gas import facilities won’t happen overnight, analysts said.

“In the European Union, there is a growing fear that US subsidies, combined with high energy costs triggered by the Russian invasion of Ukraine, might lead to the deindustrialization of Europe,” the CSIS said.

The REPowerEU plan instituted last year by the European Union aims to diversify alternative energy supplies, including renewable hydrogen and acceleration of clean energy like wind and solar that can be produced domestically.

“Around 30% of EU primary steel production is expected to be decarbonized on the basis of renewable hydrogen by 2030,” the European Commission said in the plan.

According to the CSIS, the EU has already sped up installments and deployment of other renewable energy production.

“New solar power installations grew by 47% in 2022, equivalent to the power needs of 12.4 million European homes,” the CSIS report stated. “Although volatile costs generated strong headwinds for wind-turbine suppliers, new wind capacity also expanded moderately in 2022, with onshore wind accounting for about 90% of this growth. It is estimated that growth in wind and solar capacity may have saved it $11 billion in gas imports since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.”

For now, at least, catastrophic fears of an energy-based economic collapse have been abated. The “what ifs” come back into play when thinking about the winter months of late 2023 and early 2024.

What to read next
The polls officially opened in the US on Tuesday November 5 for the presidential election pitting incumbent Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump.
Asian steel hot-rolled coil prices have had difficulty rising in recent weeks due to a number of major themes in the market, sources told Fastmarkets.
Fastmarkets’ weekly price assessments for Polish long steel were published on Thursday October 31, one day ahead of schedule due to a public holiday in Poland on November 1.
Jinnan Iron & Steel Group is the latest company to join the push to expand China's steelmaking footprint in the Middle East and is working with Brazil's Vale to establish an iron ore concentration plant at the Sohar Port and Freezone in Oman, Fastmarkets understands.
China and India are ramping up electrical steel production through new joint ventures and acquisitions to meet rising global demand and sustainability goals.
A new Chinese state-owned enterprise (SOE) called China Resources Recycling Group (CRRG) has been established to build a national platform for recycling and reusing resources, according to an announcement from Chinese officials on October 18. While details of the company's specific plans remain scarce, market participants remain concerned about weak market fundamentals, sources told Fastmarkets..