LME nickel suits reach at least $581 million | Hotter Commodities

The London Metal Exchange is facing lawsuits seeking damages collectively worth more than half a billion dollars for losses that investors allege they suffered as a result of nickel trades being canceled by the exchange last year

There are five main suits, filed within a year of the cancellations on March 8, 2022, each claiming a breach of human rights.

The biggest financial claim, by Elliot Management Corp, is worth more than $456 million.

The next largest, from a group led by AQR Capital Management, is worth around $96 million, followed by a suit led by Jane Street for $15.34 million.

Investors led by Commodity Asset Management LLC are seeking more than $12 million in damages, while UK-based Double Eight is claiming more than $2.42 million, according to the LME’s owner, Hong Kong exchanges & Clearing (HKEX).

Elliot and Jane Street have been granted permission to proceed with their suits, which HKEX says are “without merit.”

The claims collectively total more than $581.76 million, an eye-watering amount of money for the LME, which generated $1.34 billion in revenue for HKEX last year.

Legal fees are mounting, contributing to a 12% rise in HKEX’s operating expenses last year, the company said in its 2022 results. Of course, if the LME wins, then it will be awarded costs, which are typically 60% of its expenses in any suit.

The defendants are separately alleging that, under Article 1 of the First Protocol of the European Convention on Human Rights (A1P1), the decision by the LME interfered with private contracts, or possessions.

What happened when the LME suspended nickel trading?

It’s not entirely difficult to understand the ire of market participants – after all, on March 7 and 8, LME nickel prices rose by a stunning 250%. The majority of the gains came in early London trading on March 8, when the price leapt above $100,000 per tonne, having closed at an already surprising $48,078 per tonne the prior day.

But the exchange maintains that its decision to suspend trading and cancel trades was taken because the nickel market had become disorderly.

“Cancellations were made retrospectively to take the market back to the last point in time at which the LME could be confident that the market was operating in an orderly manner. It should be stressed that the LME always acted in the interests of the market as a whole,” HKEX recently said.

Theoretical rights and wrongs of the arguments aside, the LME rulebook clearly states that, “where the exchange considers it appropriate, the exchange may cancel, vary or correct any agreed trade or contract.”

LME facing an enforcement investigation by FCA

Perhaps a bigger cloud hanging over the exchange is the fact that the LME is facing an enforcement investigation by its regulator, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).

Unlike the lawsuits, which had been widely expected following some very public commentary by the investor community about the nickel situation, the FCA enforcement investigation took the market by surprise. It is also likely to drag on for at least another year, probably longer.

None of it is helpful for the LME, which has been struggling to rebuild confidence in its nickel contract and has led to the exploration of alternatives.

For years, the LME has been targeting money managers – hedge funds, commodity trade advisory players, asset managers and pension funds – with the goal of increasing their use of the exchange.

Known as the Liquidity Roadmap, it was designed to boost participation and enhance liquidity, and it included the launch of market-making programs for the first time in the LME’s history.

Eight years on, and getting the speculative and investor-led community to fully embrace the LME is still proving a somewhat elusive goal.

In Hotter Commodities, special correspondent Andrea Hotter covers some of the biggest stories impacting the natural resources sector. Sign up today to receive Andrea’s content as it is published.

What to read next
Join us for the Fastmarkets Asian Battery Materials Conference in Singapore. Don’t miss out on a packed agenda. Find out some key reasons to attend
The Critical Raw Materials Act (CRMA) proposed by the European Commission has been welcomed by stakeholders familiar with the nascent European battery ecosystem as a step toward achieving a sustainable and reliable supply of materials vital to the region’s ambitious energy transition goals
The European Union’s much-anticipated Critical Raw Materials Act, announced on Thursday March 16 by European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen, has set out new lists of the raw materials now formally designated as strategic and critical
India is increasing efforts to secure supplies of the critical raw materials needed for energy transition by exploiting its internal resources and building partnerships with foreign countries
Continued tightness of class one supply within Europe and increased buying interest amid falling London Metal Exchange nickel prices and fresh liquidity have prompted an increase in premiums within Europe, while US and Chinese premiums remain steady for now
China’s automotive sector output and sales showed double-digit increases on both a monthly and an annual basis in February 2023, thanks to support from local governments as well as carmakers’ own sales promotions, according to the China Association of Automobile Manufacturers (CAAM)
We use cookies to provide a personalized site experience.
By continuing to use & browse the site you agree to our Privacy Policy.