North American builders’ sentiment is historically poor amid high mortgage rates

Wood products sales are linked heavily to residential construction, and builders, with a keen awareness of the housing market, have not shown much confidence in recent months

Since July, the National Association of Home Builders’ (NAHB)/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index (HMI), a gauge of builders’ sentiment, has dropped 22 points to its lowest level since December of last year.

November’s reading was 34, down 6 points from the prior month. The monthly average since 1985 is 52, two points higher than the demarcation between a positive outlook on home sales and a reading below 50 signaling an unfavorable outlook.

Builder opinion linked to rising mortgage rates in the US

Builders’ sentiment often falls with the rise of mortgage rates, as seen in the accompanying chart. So, it is no surprise that housing starts can also be thrown in the mix, as they adjust to builders’ perceptions as to whether homes they build can be sold profitably.

According to the NAHB, many homebuilders are now reducing the prices of recently constructed homes to increase sales. In November, 36% of builders reported cutting home prices, tying the previous high in the current cycle set last November.

All three components of the HMI declined in November. The index gauging current sales conditions dropped six points to 40. Sales expectations over the next six months fell five points, and the component measuring traffic of prospective buyers dropped five points.

However, not all is doom and gloom. Mortgage interest rates have dropped significantly in recent weeks from a high of 7.79% to 7.22%, which is likely to boost builders’ outlook on the market. Inflation has cooled, and the Fed’s rate hikes have been suspended, with some even talking about them being cut. 

Want to learn more about the lumber market, prices, or forecasts? Check out our dedicated page for timber/lumber, other wood products, or speak to our team about accessing our news, analysis, forecasts and more.

What to read next
Read about the fluctuations in Canadian housing starts, the factors influencing the market and their implications for real estate in Canada.
Access a snippet of our weekly lumber commentary, which features our expert analysis on the fifth consecutive weekly price gain.
Fastmarkets/RISI economist Dustin Jalbert noted that temporary downtime and quiet, unannounced cutbacks contributed to reduced capacity in 2024.
Industry titans from the packaging world convened in Chicago this week at the Fastmarkets’ Forest Products North America Conference & International Containerboard Conference. Read our key takeaways from the CEO discussion panels below.
In late September, the People’s Bank of China (PBOC) announced a cut in the existing mortgage rate by an average of 50 basis points.
Packagers moving from plastic to paper, particularly Amazon’s work to eliminate plastic bubble wrap with paper, contributed to the increase in shipments.