North American lumber market feels less robust in 2023 than the numbers show

Although the numbers would suggest a positive first half of 2023, sentiment and anecdotes don’t seem to back that up

Anyone who has dealt with a hard to ignite burner or a stubborn car knows the feeling. You work and work to finally get it started, only to have it peter out shortly afterwards.

Framing lumber traders could be forgiven for feeling that way about the market so far this year.

Through the first seven months of 2023, the Random Lengths Framing Lumber Composite Price (FLCP) has had three upswings. The first one, in January and early February, lasted five weeks and the composite gained a total of $73 during that span.

The second spurt ran from mid-March through mid-April. In a span of six weeks, the FLCP was flat twice and gained a total of $18 over the other four weeks.

The third run went from mid-June and went six weeks through mid-July. The total gain over that period was $81. Through the end of July, the FLCP had gone up 15 weeks thus far in 2023, dropped for 12 weeks, and was flat for the other three weeks. At the end of 2022 the FLCP sat at $380, while it was $463 at the end of July 2023.

First half of 2023 compares favorably to previous years

Based simply on the numbers, the first seven months of 2023 weren’t too bad in the lumber markets. While a gain of $83 since the end of last year may not seem like much, it compares quite favorably not only to what transpired the last couple of years, but historically as well.

In 2022, the FLCP plummeted $389 through the end of July when compared to how the previous year ended. That was nearly identical to the $395 drop registered in the previous year. In 2020, soaring demand early in the covid-19 pandemic pushed the price up a record $254 in that period.

Over the last 10 years, the FLCP gain in the first seven months of 2023 is the highest aside from 2020 (chart), and the most since a $137 gain in the like period of 2004. The FLCP has gained in six of the last 10 years, including five straight years from 2016 to 2020.

Although the numbers would suggest a positive first half of 2023, sentiment and anecdotes don’t seem to back that up. A sense of confidence among buyers and a willingness to speculate are often evident in positive markets.

Instead, a particular concern among traders this year has been the ongoing lack of interest and urgency from buyers. Throughout 2023 to date, buyers have become accustomed to being able to wait until the last minute and fill in holes with prompt truckloads, or even partial truckloads. Speculative purchases have been next to nil for many months.

In addition, the strongest run thus far in 2023, the third one, came on the heels of a surprisingly strong May US housing report. There was plenty of skepticism about the robust numbers in the report, and once the revised and drastically lower numbers came out a month later, any sense of urgency disappeared from the market.

As such, traders have tended to look at that third run – as well as the other two shorter, modest upticks – as examples of the fire in the market not being sustained after initially catching. Each of the three times, producers felt things were finally going somewhere. Each time, modest gains realized were quickly washed away and buyers only came off the sidelines to plug pressing holes.

Want to learn more about the lumber market, prices, or forecasts? Check out our dedicated page for timber/lumber, other wood products, or speak to our team about accessing our news, analysis, forecasts and more.

What to read next
The recent volatility of wood product raw materials prices significantly impacts the US housing market, influencing both demand and supply in construction. With pressure mounting in the framing lumber and structural panel markets, the fluctuating cost of these essential materials creates a ripple effect affecting pricing, project timelines and ultimately the availability of new homes. […]
Some major producers that started up new and converted paper and board machines in the last year-plus, as well as the largest containerboard makers in the US, are still paying hefty premiums to secure old corrugated containers (OCC), and they sought more mixed paper as supply constraint concerns continued midyear. Contacts told Fastmarkets’ PPI Pulp & […]
No feedback was received during the consultation period and therefore no changes will be made to the methodologies at this stage. This consultation sought to ensure that our methodologies continue to reflect the physical market under indexation, in compliance with the International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO) principles for Price Reporting Agencies (PRAs). This includes […]
North American softwood lumber exports to offshore destinations posted mild gains in the first quarter, sustaining the momentum evident in the second half of 2023. Want to predict the future of the lumber market? Learn more about our short-term and long-term forecasts and asset analysis for the global forest products market today. Learn more. Canadian exports overseas reached […]
Paper Excellence Group (PE) informed North American customers its baled paper grade bleached softwood kraft (BSK) market pulp prices will increase, effective May 1, Fastmarkets has learned. Richmond, BC-headquartered PE announced a northern bleached softwood kraft (NBSK) list price of $1,690/tonne. PE did not state how much that’s up, however it is $80/tonne higher than […]
What factors are driving the significant downturn in US housing starts, accompanied by a decrease in building permits?