Decarbonization in the steel industry creating two-tiered iron ore market

The iron ore market is expected to diverge into two segments in line with the steelmaking industry’s march toward reducing carbon emissions, Fastmarkets learned at the 2024 Singapore Iron Ore Forum (SIOF) on Tuesday May 7

Eduardo de Mello Franco, Marketing Manager of iron ore pricing at Vale said that structural undersupply of high-grade iron ore, which is projected to tip 70 million tonnes by 2030, is expected to drive a wedge between mid-grade iron ore sinter fines and high-grade iron ore.

Structural supply-demand deficit supports long-term premiums on high-grade green iron ore

Franco added that the expansion of carbon neutral steelmaking feedstocks like direct reduced iron (DRI) in response to the establishment of more rigorous carbon reporting and pricing is expected to put a strong premium on specialized ores that help to reduce emissions vis a vis other mid-grade ores.

Speaking in the high-grade iron ore panel at the SIOF, Renato Hendrikson, head of strategic marketing at Samarco said that the fundamental tightness high-grade iron ore supply amid the expansion of global DRI production capacity necessitates a differentiated pricing approach compared with direct shipping ores (DSO).

Diverging functions of iron ore usage

Hendrikson added that the predominant function of high-grade pellet feed is vastly different from most DSO, which require a coal-intensive process of sintering to be used in blast furnaces (BFs).

High-grade iron ore pellet feed, which typically has an iron content of 67% and above and a combined gangue (silica + alumina content) of less than 3.5%, is commonly the feedstock in the production of direct-reduced (DR) pellets, which are then in turn used to produce DRI – a feedstock for steel production with the electrical-arc furnace (EAF), alongside scrap or pig iron.

EAF steelmaking with the use of DRI paves the way for a less carbon intensive form of steelmaking, offering a scalable solution for steelmakers to directly reduce carbon output, according to Siddarth Aggarwal, manager and book owner at Anglo American.

The opportunity cost of lower metallurgical coal consumption should also be used in differentiating high-grade iron ore with DSO, according to Russell Wescombe, Senior Business Manager at Grange Resources.

Wescombe added that the increased regulatory scrutiny on carbon-intensive production methods like iron ore sintering with DSO is expected to incur additional costs in the coming years, incentivizing a pivot toward lower-carbon raw materials.

Lower-cost DSO to remain as mainstay in major BF steelmaking hubs in China, India

Most market participants were of the view that the predominant role of BF steelmaking in China and in rapidly expanding markets like India is expected to reinforce the integral position of DSO in global iron ore trade flows.

Speaking at the panel on South Asian steel production, Vivek Nishant Nath, General Manager of Sales and Marketing at Odisha Mining Corporation (OMC) said that low to mid-grade sinter ore between 57-62% Fe will form the bulk India’s steelmaking raw material demand while it navigates toward its annual production target of 300 million tonnes of steel by 2030.

China’s sinter fines demand is also expected to remain stable toward the end of the decade despite a slowdown in steel production, considering the relative age of most BFs across China alongside China’s penchant for low-cost steel production, sources said.

The two-tiered iron ore market which is expected to serve two varied functions towards steelmaking will ultimately trade on different pricing fundamentals due to differences in supply, demand and ultimately function, where high-grade iron ore will trade at a differentiated premium.

Follow the low-carbon steel discussion and keep up-to-date with the developments influencing the decarbonization of the steel industry. Learn more.

Follow the low-carbon steel discussion and keep up-to-date with the developments influencing the decarbonization of the steel industry

What to read next
The use of green hydrogen to produce direct-reduced iron (DRI) is set to transform the steelmaking industry, an executive from Ferrexpo has said
Chinese domestic authorities are in discussions to implement tighter targets on crude steel production across the country, in a bid to reduce energy consumption and carbon emissions, Fastmarkets understands
The publication of Fastmarkets’ MB-IRO-0186 iron ore DR grade pellet premium indicator for Wednesday June 12 was delayed due to an error in the review process.
A “special action plan for carbon reduction” unveiled by China's National Development & Reform Commission (NDRC) will reduce the need for coking coal and iron ore by focusing on upgrading existing equipment and the switch to electric-arc furnaces, sources told Fastmarkets this week
Fastmarkets has corrected its MB-IRO-0190 Iron ore spot 67.5% Fe magnetite-hematite pellet feed price differential, cfr Qingdao, $/tonne, which was published incorrectly on Monday May 13.
The publication of Fastmarkets’ lithium, iron ore and Chinese ferrous prices for Monday April 22 were delayed because of technical issues.