‘Green steel’ premiums to become commonplace within the next decade

Additional premiums for low-carbon ‘green steel’ are still a niche market, but will they become the norm in the next three-to-10 years? The answer is yes, according to the expert panelists at Fastmarkets’ International Iron Ore conference in Düsseldorf, Germany, in early June

Green steel is a niche market because it’s fairly new, but it will eventually become a license to operate,” Anesan Naidoo, Anglo American’s head of sales and trading (iron ore) said on Wednesday, June 8.

And Luisa Orre, chief procurement officer at Swedish start-up H2 Green Steel, said on Tuesday that “demand for high-grade green steel is definitely here.”

H2 Geen Steel is planning to produce hydrogen-based steel from 2024-2025. And its customers have already expressed an interest in, and are willing to pay a premium for, more environmentally friendly steel, Orre said.

Additional costs incurred producing green steel can be passed on to customers in the same way as additional costs to produce organic and ethical food have been passed on to the general public, she said, predicting more liquidity in green steel premiums in the coming years.

Green steel is generally defined as steel with less than 0.6 tonnes of CO2 emissions per tonne of steel produced. The steel industry is currently responsible for 7-9% of global CO2 emissions and is on a journey to decarbonize using low-carbon materials such as high-grade iron ore and scrap and new technologies such as green hydrogen-based direct reduction.

“Green steel premiums are coming,” Lee Kirk, managing director for metals at Cargill, said on Tuesday. “We expect a shortage of 5-15 million tonnes of green flat steel in Europe by 2030. It’s going to be in scarce resource.”

The steel industry is behind other sectors, such as battery producers, in terms of environmental, social, and corporate governance (ESG) and investing in greener technologies and raw materials and it needs at least 5-10 more years of investment into projects for greener raw materials, according to Kirk.

“Carbon pricing, energy pricing and green premiums are all intertwined with one another. We will see higher carbon pricing and more green premiums being introduced to the market. Access to green steel has drawn interest but supply in the industry is still tight. Green premiums will evolve eventually and [will become] more viable,” Kirk said.

Premiums for green iron ore?

In the same way that steelmakers are pushing for the introduction of green premiums, iron ore producers have this week introduced the idea of green premiums for low-carbon iron ore and warned of the days when customers will only accept to buy iron ore from ESG-certified miners.

“It’s very early days but we do see it coming,” according to Chris McMahen, group manager of technical marketing at Australian iron ore producer FMG Fortescue,

He said that iron ore premiums would need to be negotiated between miners and steelmakers for some time, but added that the premium for ‘green iron ore’ is likely to be a much smaller proportion of the overall price than the premium for green steel.

What to read next
Higher costs resulting from a tentative deal to end the strike at East Coast and Gulf Coast ports could reduce imports, increase reshoring and drive up the cost of steel products in the US, according to market observers and participants
Fastmarkets is launching a green long steel differential to its weekly price assessment for steel reinforcing bar (rebar) import, cfr Singapore, as well as a weekly inferred green steel base price for rebar cfr Singapore.
The heightened importance for the steel reinforcing bar (rebar) industry was apparent to market participants immediately, and has expanded to include multiple arms of the wider construction sector, including merchant bar, beams and wire rod, according to multiple sources in the rebar and general construction markets contacted by Fastmarkets on Wednesday October 2. The Category 4 […]
Fastmarkets heard from green steel producers, buyers and stakeholders at the annual Climate Week NYC event, held from September 22 to September 29
European steelmakers are committed to the decarbonization of the industry and are shifting to more environmentally friendly ways of working, despite the recent economic downturn making it more challenging to charge a premium for “green” steel, sources told Fastmarkets.
New mining frontiers were emerging but, ahead of the London Metal Exchange’s LME Week event, industry executives have warned of a supply squeeze, with regulatory hurdles and the costs of being ‘green’ hindering the production of copper and other critical minerals