Prospects improving for green steel premium: distributors

Willingness to pay for steel that advances decarbonization and sustainability goals is gaining ground, suggesting that premium pricing for green steel could be implemented and marking a turnaround from views in the recent past, according to leading service center executives

“The quickest way to break up a social circle five years ago was to talk about this, [but now] more customers are talking about it [and] it’s clearly more of a top-line issue,” Edward Lehner, president and chief executive officer at industrial metals distributor and processor Ryerson, said at Fastmarkets’ Steel Success Strategies conference on Tuesday June 7.

The questions right now are the dollar value that might be set for the green steel premium and when buyers might be ready to pay the premium, Lehner said in a panel discussion on steel distribution amid supply-chain issues.

The answer? “It really depends upon the choices we make as a society,” Lehner said.

The government could adopt policies that either create incentives for buyers to pay a premium for green steel – or be punitive and impose penalties for those who do not, Lehner said. If a policy based on incentives was chosen, the government would need to decide what customers receive in return for paying a premium for green steel.

Policy makers also will need to decide on how ambitious they want to make their goals, Ryerson said.

“Do they want to get to net zero [carbon emissions]?” he asked.

Decarbonization is “really a hot topic,” panelist Todd Lebow, chief executive officer and president of distributor and metals processor Majestic Steel, agreed. “I think sustainability is not just a trend right now, but we’re trying to figure out what that means, how to manage and how to create value for your company.”

Regarding the implementation of a premium, Lebow said it depends on the specific companies and who is asking for green steel to be offered.

“Is it their investor pool? Their customer pool? Are they going to generate value for it?” Lebow asked. “If they can create value for it, then they’re going to pay for it,” Lebow said, meaning that if buyers find value in green steel, then they will be willing to pay for it.

Lebow pointed out that different options at the grocery store demonstrate how this can work, noting that shoppers can find milk and produce that are advertised as organic or produced locally and that charge a premium.

“If you care about this, then you’ll pay for it. If not, then you won’t,” he said. “Do you care more about the branding of green steel? Then you can go out to the market and say it’s green steel.”

Government policies also could successfully usher in green steel premium pricing.

“If you’re regulated to [offer, produce or purchase green steel], you’re going to do it. If not you’re not, you’re not,” he argued.

An instant poll of the audience at the conference during the panel discussion found that 31% of those present reported seeing demand for low-carbon steel products, while 69% reported seeing no demand.

The automotive industry may be a leading candidate for paying a green steel premium, according to Jörg Brinckmann, head of ironmaking and green steel at SMS Group, who participated in panel on decarbonization strategies.

The implementation of a green steel premium might have other effects on the market, according to Kerry Deal, head of business development, Freight Investor Services, who spoke in a separate panel on risk-management strategies.

“It will drive people to understand carbon offsets. The necessity of very large cash investments by many steel mills – particularly in Europe but in the US, too – to go greener will also probably make hedging on their outputs and inputs more attractive, as a necessity, as a way to remain more competitive and control costs,” Deal said.

Grace Asenov in New York contributed to this report.

What to read next
The gloomy economic tone at the conference was compensated by the large numbers of delegates in attendance and cheerful networking. 1. Slow growth in China Slow growth in China continued to spook market participants. Those who have recently returned from trips there shared anecdotes and photographs on social media of blue skies and a lack […]
The MENA region is already well equipped to produce cheap, green hydrogen because of its extensive solar resources, but the fact that its steel industry is mainly focused on the use of direct-reduced iron (DRI) modules and electric-arc furnaces puts it in a unique position in terms of producing the low-carbon steel that is becoming […]
While daily crude steel production stood at 2 million tonnes in mid-October, a 1.25% decrease from the previous year according to data published by China’s Iron and Steel Association (CISA), overall production has remained relatively firm following a strong first half of 2023. With no clear indications of a rebound in downstream steel prices in […]
Talks between the European Union and the United States began in October 2021, where both parties announced the Global Arrangement on Sustainable Steel and Aluminium (GASSA), a partnership in which both parties would negotiate an arrangement to combat global overcapacity and climate change. The discussions would include discouraging trade in high-carbon steel and aluminum that […]
NANO has targeted remote mining operations run by diesel fuel in locations where the logistics of providing a constant source of fuel “may be a challenge,” the CEO said. The company’s microreactors could also expand mining opportunities to more new locations. “It can make thousands of potential mines economic and come online, whereas before, they […]
US steel scrap prices ahead of November trade The Trend Indicator has rebounded into bullish territory, at 61.4 for November compared with a resolutely bearish 45.6 in October. This month’s indicator is at its highest since March’s outlook, when it was 65.2. The Outlook’s prediction model allows for an average month-on-month price increase of 5.1%. Respondents […]